Best Fence Materials for Indiana Homes: Vinyl, Aluminum, Wood & Chain Link

If you’re thinking about fence installation in Indiana, you’ve probably noticed the quotes can vary—sometimes a little, sometimes a lot. The truth is, not all fences (or installers) are created equal. Weather, materials, soil, and installation techniques all play a role in how long your fence will last and how much it will cost.

This guide covers the most popular fence materials in Indiana—vinyl, aluminum, wood, and chain link—so you know what you’re really paying for, what lasts, and how to avoid costly mistakes.

Vinyl Fences in Indiana: The Good, the Bad, and the Truth

This 6-foot tan vinyl privacy fence with a decorative lattice top was professionally installed by U.S. Fence and Supply right here in Mooresville, Indiana. Homeowners love this durable, low-maintenance fence style for both privacy and curb appeal.

Vinyl fencing is one of the best choices for Indiana weather. It’s durable, comes in multiple heights, colors, and styles, and works for both residential and commercial applications. But not all vinyl is equal.

• Cheap vinyl fencing is brittle and poorly made. Panels sag over time, posts crack easily, and they’re more prone to damage from lawn equipment, pets, and general wear. Unfortunately, these low-quality options are still fairly expensive—and everybody has access to them.

  
  

• Commercial-grade vinyl fencing is another level entirely. Posts, pickets, and rails are thicker, quality control is higher, and many systems include metal inserts in the bottom rails to prevent sagging.

  
  

💡 Pro Tip: Yes, commercial-grade vinyl costs more upfront, but it pays off with a nearly maintenance-free, long-lasting fence. For homeowners who want privacy and durability, it’s a “buy once, cry once” solution.

One thing to note: colored vinyl (tan, gray, brown) can fade over time due to UV exposure. Higher-grade vinyl holds color better and maintains that crisp look.

Aluminum Fences: The Versatile, Low-Maintenance Option

Check out this 4-foot black aluminum fence with a 3-rail smooth top installed by U.S. Fence and Supply in Indianapolis, Indiana. This sleek, durable aluminum fencing option adds both security and style to residential properties.

Aluminum fences are one of the most versatile and cost-effective options for Indiana homeowners. They cost less than vinyl, last just as long (or longer), and are approved by many HOAs as the standard non-privacy fence.

• Durability: Aluminum stands strong in snow, rain, and heat. Most manufacturers use a powder-coated finish that resists rust and fading.

  
  

• Maintenance: Easy to touch up if scratched, and repainting is simple and affordable.

  
  

• Styles: Available in many heights and designs, though the most common are 4–5 foot black 3-rail smooth top or spear top. These fences add a sleek, upscale look to any property.

  
  

🐾 Puppy Picket Option: For pet owners, some aluminum fences come with “puppy pickets”—extra verticals that reduce gaps from 3.5" down to 1.5–2", making them perfect for keeping small dogs secure.

If privacy isn’t your main concern, aluminum is an excellent blend of functionality, curb appeal, and longevity.

Wood Fences: Classic, Affordable, and Customizable

This 6-foot wood privacy fence was installed by U.S. Fence and Supply in Ellettsville, Indiana. A timeless choice for homeowners, wood fencing offers both privacy and a natural look that blends beautifully with any property.

Wood fences sometimes get a bad reputation, but with quality materials and proper installation, they can last 15+ years in Indiana.

Yes, wood will naturally bow, twist, or crack over time—it’s part of the material. But smart installation techniques and regular maintenance (staining, sealing) minimize these issues.

• Styles Beyond Privacy: Don’t write off wood as “cheap.” Options like board-on-board, shadowbox, cedar upgrades, cap and trim, or custom scallops/arches can create a fence that’s both timeless and unique.

  
  

• Versatility: Wood remains one of the most affordable and customizable materials.

Here’s a custom board-on-board wood privacy fence with cap and trim installed by U.S. Fence and Supply in Columbus, Indiana. This premium wood design provides maximum privacy with an upgraded finished look homeowners love.

🚩 Red Flag Alert: If a contractor dodges questions or says “the installer can explain later,” walk away. Hire a trusted local fence company that builds with care—like U.S. Fence & Supply.

Chain Link Fences: Affordable and Functional

Chain link is one of the most affordable fencing options for Indiana yards—and it’s better looking than many give it credit for.

• Durability: Chain link can take a beating from weather, pets, and play without failing.

  
  

• Cost: Typically falls in the lower range of installation pricing, making it great for budget-conscious homeowners.

  
  

• Aesthetic Options: Black or green coated chain link blends into landscapes surprisingly well when installed correctly.

  
  

For functionality and cost savings, chain link remains timeless.

Fence Installation Costs in Indiana: What to Expect

Pricing fences isn’t one-size-fits-all. Costs depend on:

his upscale 5-foot black aluminum fence with a smooth 3-rail top was installed by U.S. Fence and Sup

This custom wood privacy fence partition with a gate was installed by U.S. Fence and Supply in Terre

• Material and grade of materials

• Total footage and number of gates

• Soil conditions and terrain (slopes, rocks, clay)

• Site accessibility (tight yards vs. wide open)

• Obstacles (pools, patios, sheds, trees)

• Timeline and labor availability

  
  

That said, here are average Indiana ranges we’ve seen for backyard projects:

• Chain Link: $2,500–$5,000+

• Wood & Aluminum: $3,500–$6,500+

• Vinyl: $5,000–$10,000+

  
  

⚠️ Remember: These are just ballpark numbers. We’ve installed fences from as little as $1,000 to well over $10,000. The key is to be prepared so you’re not hit with “sticker shock.”

Why Professional Installation Matters

Even the best materials will fail if installed poorly. Indiana’s soil and weather require experienced installers who understand:

• Correct post depth and concrete footing for freeze-thaw cycles.

• How to handle grading and uneven ground.

• Local permits and HOA rules.

• Proper material handling to prevent warping or sagging.

  
  

And don’t forget—always get a signed contract or written agreement before moving forward. It protects both you and your contractor.

Looking for Ways to Save? Try DIY Kits

U.S. Fence and Supply delivers black chain link DIY fence kits straight to homeowners, ready for installation. These complete packages make it easy to get a durable, low-maintenance chain link fence without the hassle, perfect for DIY projects and cost-conscious homeowners.

If you’ve gotten quotes that are higher than expected, there’s another option: DIY fence kits.

At U.S. Fence & Supply, we offer pre-packaged fence kits with all the parts you need, delivered to your home or job site. You’ll save thousands on labor while still getting professional-grade materials. And you won’t be alone—our team provides installation guidance and support to help you get it right the first time.

DIY Fence Kits: Build Your Fence with Support from Start to Finish

Final Word: Built Right, Built Once

Indiana homeowners have choices—but cutting corners on materials or contractors usually costs more in the end. Whether you’re considering vinyl, aluminum, wood, or chain link, the right fence installed by a trusted local team will serve your family for years.

👉 Ready for a fence that lasts? Contact U.S. Fence & Supply today for a free estimate—or ask us about our DIY fence kits to save big on labor.

Get A Free Estimate Today!